IBM goes for SCO jugular in test of GPL validity

Keywords: Match:

Aug. 19, 2004

IBM has turned the tables on SCO in a maneuver that could provide the first major legal test of the GNU General Public License (GPL), and which could leave SCO all but unable to continue selling and supporting products based on Linux and Unix.

In a motion for partial summary judgement filed August 16 in a Utah court, IBM asserts that SCO lost its right to distribute GPL code, including 16 packages copyrighted to IBM, when it "renounced, disclaimed, and breached" the GPL. Should the IBM motion succeed, SCO's ability to do business in the computer industry would be drastically curtailed, given the large amount of software not only in Linux but also in Unix that is now licensed under the GPL.

According to the IBM filing, "The GPL and LGPL provide that a person may rely on the GPL or LGPL as a license or grant of permission ... only if the person abides by the terms of the GPL or LGPL."

The IBM filing goes on to assert that SCO failed to abide by the terms of the GPL when it "repudiated and disclaimed" the GPL, claiming the GPL (IBM quoting SCO, here) "is unenforceable, void and/or voidable" and "violates the U.S. Constitution, together with copyright, antitrust and export control laws."

IBM further asserts that SCO breached the GPL "at least as early as May 2003 and thus... automatically lost any rights it might have had under the GPL and LGPL to copy and distribute the IBM Copyrighted Works."

Specifically, IBM asserts that SCO violated the GPL when it attempted to collect royalties or licensing fees for the use of Linux (see this article for a brief history of SCO's efforts to extract royalties from Linux users, including embedded Linux users). According to IBM, in a memorandum in support of its motion, the GPL expressly forbids a person distributing GPL code from adding "further restrictions" such as royalties or licensing fees, except for the "physical act of transferring a copy" -- reproduction fees, in other words.

Despite its attacks on and violations of the GPL, SCO continued to distribute products such as its SCO Linux 4.0 that included IBM copyrighted software (among many other GPL- and LGPL-licensed packages), offering the products for public download from its Internet site as recently as August 4 of this year, according to IBM.

The IBM memo sums up the case neatly in this sentence: "By its breaches of the GPL and LGPL, SCO has forfeited any protection against claims of copyright infringement that it may have enjoyed by virtue fo the GPL or LGPL."

Thus, through its "motion for summary judgment," IBM is attempting to extract a ruling from a court of law "summarily," that is, without further debate, that SCO should no longer be allowed to distribute GPL code.

Open source software licensing expert Bruce Perens summed up the motion this way, "IBM's going for the jugular."

Perens said that if the motion succeeds, SCO won't have to withdraw previous software that they've distributed. "But it's possible they may have to remedy copyright," he added, suggesting SCO could be forced to pay damages to IBM and other copyright holders of GPL software that it distributed.

Asked if he thought the IBM motion would carry, Perens was neutral, suggesting the motion could be denied if the judge felt the matter might be more appropriate to a separate case.

Groklaw has published a brief story about IBM's motion against SCO. The story includes links to copies of several relevant documents.

The full text of Version 2 of the GNU General Public License, under which the Linux kernel and many other open source packages are distributed, is available here.

Related Stories:

(Click here for further information)

Approaching the Linux Desktop
The purpose of this paper is to help organizations evaluate the Linux desktop against their own enterprise needs and discover what benefits the Linux desktop might bring to their organizations.

Migrating To Linux: Application Challenges and Solutions
Several solutions exist to help organizations migrate in an orderly fashion from Windows to Linux desktops. This paper establishes the characteristics of an ideal cross-platform solution and reviews these alternatives in light of this ideal standard. The paper takes a closer look at the pros and cons of various solutions and outlines the business benefits that can be achieved.

Linux Advantages: Publicly Available Information on Linux Software
This paper offers a brief summary of readily-available Linux information to help businesses sort out this widely misunderstood operating system.

Top 5 Strategies for Managing Linux
Despite continuous evolution in the manageability of Linux, a 2006 survey cited manageability concerns as a top reason why organizations are hesitating to adopt Linux. Levanta believes Linux can be as manageable, if not more so, than other operating systems by following key strategies. These strategic recommendations were developed from experiences in numerous customer environments, both large and small.

Why Choose Novell for Linux?
This paper outlines the benefits of switching to the Linux platform and choosing Novell as a high-performance, enterprise solution.

Enterprise Linux Selection Guide
Considering moving your enterprise to the Linux operating system? Since there are so many similar versions, choosing the right one can be tough. This paper offers a clear process to help you make an informed decision and get the features, support, and cost that are right for your business and technical needs.

Overcoming Challenges in Managing Linux
Levanta has created a new administration model with innovative technology that breaks down the barriers to making the most of Linux systems. This paper will provide an in-depth look at the workings of Levanta’s product, the first Linux appliance of its kind.

SUSE Linux Enterprise 10 for Retail Businesses
Discover why major retailers have switched to SUSE Linux Enterprise Desktop in the back office. SUSE Linux Enterprise Desktop 10 is a low-cost desktop that offers a complete set of productivity applications and interoperates seamlessly with the other Windows, Macintosh and UNIX desktops in your store.

Moving to a Linux Desktop
Migrating from Windows to Linux on the desktop can be a substantial undertaking because it has the potential for touching -- and perhaps disrupting -- every user in your organization. Unlike a data center (server and infrastructure) migration that is largely transparent to users, the cultural and administrative transitions and environment readiness required to support a Linux desktop migration are extensive.

Seven Good Reasons to Exchange Exchange
This paper describes seven compelling reasons why you should switch from Exchange to Scalix.

Got a HOT tip? please tell us!

ADVERTISEMENT
(Advertise here)

Popular recent stories: • Lightweight GNOME alternative emerges • WiFi software arrives on Linux desktops • BeOS-like distro focused on content creation • Lenovo launches a netbook • Linux mini-PC takes two Watts to tango • Graphics board vendor touts faster Linux drivers • Debian looks to launch lenny in Sept. • Lenovo denies ditching Linux • gOS 3.0 goes Gadget crazy • OpenSUSE 11.0 arrives All-time Classics: • Choosing a desktop Linux distro • Banshee -- the next best thing to Linux iTunes • Running World of Warcraft on Ubuntu • The Best Free Desktop Linux . . . and how to make it better • A simple Linux backup method • Linux-powered Asus Eee PC mini-laptop arrives • The well-tempered Debian desktop • What's the best Linux for beginners? • Xandros 4: The best desktop Linux for Windows users • VirtualBox: The best virtualization program you've never heard of • Getting to know Puppy Linux	Desktop Linux books Join our Desktop Linux discussion forums: • Moving to Linux • Linux/Windows debate! • Linux Q&A . . . and more

BREAKING NEWS

• Linux gains FPS
• Ubuntu tops on desktop, but not servers
• Browser swallows OS
• Tutorial reveals desktop Linux security tips
• Fedora 10 first impressions
• 8,000 TuxTop models and counting
• "Moonlight" ready to shine
• Adobe unleashes 64-bit Flash
• Debian Lenny installer arrives
• Ubuntu announces ARM port
• Amazon offers Linux XOs
• Windows 7 "no threat" to netbook Linux
• Creative frees Sound Blaster driver code
• Linux, netbooks threaten Microsoft's fat profits
• Ibex inspires GNOME switch

Linux-Watch headlines:
• Mistah SCO -- he dead
• Worst security blooper ever?
• Novell offers RHEL, CentOS support
• Windows 7 no threat to netbook Linux
• Microsoft breaks HotMail for Linux users?
• Torvalds: Real quality means taking it personally
• Opinion: open source value transcends tough times
• OpenOffice 3.0 reviewed
• Shutting down idle PCs with Linux
• Linux valued at $10.9 billion

Visit the...

news feed

Home \| News \| Articles \| Forum \| Polls \| About \| Contact

	Ziff Davis Enterprise Home \| Contact Us \| Advertise \| Link to Us \| Reprints \| Magazine Subscriptions \| Newsletters Tech RSS Feeds \| White Papers \| ROI Calculators \| Tech Podcasts \| Tech Video \| VARs \| Channel News
	Baseline \| Careers \| Channel Insider \| CIO Insight \| DesktopLinux \| DeviceForge \| DevSource \| eSeminars \| eWEEK \| Enterprise Network Security \| LinuxDevices \| Linux Watch \| Microsoft Watch \| Mid-market \| Networking \| PDF Zone \| Publish \| Security IT Hub \| Strategic Partner \| Web Buyer's Guide \| Windows for Devices
	Developer Shed \| Dev Shed \| ASP Free \| Dev Articles \| Dev Hardware \| SEO Chat \| Tutorialized \| Scripts \| Code Walkers \| Web Hosters \| Dev Mechanic \| Dev Archives \| igrep
Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Except where otherwise specified, the contents of this site are copyright © 1999-2008 Ziff Davis Enterprise Holdings Inc. All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of Ziff Davis Enterprise is prohibited. Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds. All other marks are the property of their respective owners.

Home \| News \| Articles \| Forum \| Polls \| About \| Contact

	Ziff Davis Enterprise Home \| Contact Us \| Advertise \| Link to Us \| Reprints \| Magazine Subscriptions \| Newsletters Tech RSS Feeds \| White Papers \| ROI Calculators \| Tech Podcasts \| Tech Video \| VARs \| Channel News
	Baseline \| Careers \| Channel Insider \| CIO Insight \| DesktopLinux \| DeviceForge \| DevSource \| eSeminars \| eWEEK \| Enterprise Network Security \| LinuxDevices \| Linux Watch \| Microsoft Watch \| Mid-market \| Networking \| PDF Zone \| Publish \| Security IT Hub \| Strategic Partner \| Web Buyer's Guide \| Windows for Devices
	Developer Shed \| Dev Shed \| ASP Free \| Dev Articles \| Dev Hardware \| SEO Chat \| Tutorialized \| Scripts \| Code Walkers \| Web Hosters \| Dev Mechanic \| Dev Archives \| igrep
Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Except where otherwise specified, the contents of this site are copyright © 1999-2008 Ziff Davis Enterprise Holdings Inc. All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of Ziff Davis Enterprise is prohibited. Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds. All other marks are the property of their respective owners.